Tomato Pie

There’s something irresistibly homey about a tomato pie. The aroma of ripe tomatoes roasting beneath a blanket of creamy cheese and herbs, all held together by a buttery, flaky crust, fills the kitchen with warmth and nostalgia. With each bite, you get layers of rich, savory goodness balanced by the freshness of tomatoes and the tang of mayo and herbs. It’s summer in every slice, yet comforting enough to serve year-round.

Behind the Recipe

The story of tomato pie began in my grandmother’s kitchen. Every summer, her countertops overflowed with tomatoes from the garden. Some became sauces, others were sliced with just a pinch of salt. But the most magical transformation? Tomato pie. She’d hum as she layered juicy slices over her homemade crust, dotting it with creamy mayo and herbs before blanketing it with shredded cheese. That scent wafting through her screen door meant dinner was near and delicious.

Recipe Origin or Trivia

While tomato pie is often associated with the American South, there are actually two distinct versions. The Southern version, which we’re making today, is a savory dish with cheese, herbs, and tomatoes baked in a pie crust. There’s also a lesser-known variation from the Northeastern U.S., especially in Utica, New York, which is more of a bread-based pizza-like dish. But this creamy, cheesy, tomato-forward version? It’s a Southern staple that sings of warm weather, backyard gardens, and potluck tables.

Why You’ll Love Tomato Pie

Let me tell you, this recipe has everything you could want in a crowd-pleasing dish. Here’s why it deserves a spot in your rotation:

Versatile: Serve it as a brunch star, a light dinner, or a side dish. It fits in anywhere.
Budget-Friendly: Tomatoes, mayo, and cheese make this a pantry-friendly recipe that won’t break the bank.
Quick and Easy: With a pre-made crust, this comes together in a snap.
Customizable: Add bacon, fresh basil, or swap cheeses to make it your own.
Crowd-Pleasing: Everyone from picky eaters to foodies will love its savory comfort.
Make-Ahead Friendly: Bake it in the morning and serve it at room temp later.
Great for Leftovers: Tastes even better the next day as flavors deepen.

Chef’s Pro Tips for Perfect Results

Tomato pie might seem simple, but a few smart tips will make yours unforgettable.

1. Salt and Drain Your Tomatoes: Salt sliced tomatoes and let them sit to draw out moisture. This prevents a soggy pie.
2. Use a Cheese Blend: Combining sharp cheddar with mozzarella or Monterey Jack adds depth and meltiness.
3. Blind Bake the Crust: Pre-bake your pie crust slightly to keep it crisp under the filling.
4. Layer Wisely: Start with a thin layer of cheese, then tomatoes, then more cheese. This keeps things melty and flavorful.
5. Let It Rest: Allow the pie to cool slightly before slicing so the filling sets nicely.

Kitchen Tools You’ll Need

This pie is straightforward, and you likely have everything you need already:

Pie Dish: A 9-inch pie dish gives the perfect size and shape.
Sharp Knife: For slicing tomatoes cleanly without squishing.
Cutting Board: Always helpful when prepping ingredients.
Mixing Bowl: To blend your mayo, herbs, and cheese.
Paper Towels: For drying out those tomato slices.

Ingredients in Tomato Pie

This tomato pie brings together simple ingredients in the most flavorful way. Let’s break down the essentials:

1. Pie Crust: 1 9-inch crust (store-bought or homemade) — Provides the buttery base that holds everything together.
2. Tomatoes: 4 large ripe tomatoes, sliced — The star of the dish, juicy and sweet.
3. Salt: 1 teaspoon — Draws out excess moisture from the tomatoes.
4. Mayonnaise: 1/2 cup — Adds creaminess and binds the filling.
5. Shredded Cheddar Cheese: 1 cup — Brings sharp, rich flavor and melt.
6. Mozzarella Cheese: 1/2 cup — Adds that perfect gooey stretch.
7. Fresh Basil: 1/4 cup, chopped — Delivers a fresh herbal note.
8. Green Onions: 2, sliced — For a mild onion flavor and color.
9. Black Pepper: 1/2 teaspoon — Adds just the right touch of spice.
10. Olive Oil: 1 tablespoon — Lightly brushed on crust or drizzled on top for richness.

Ingredient Substitutions

Sometimes you need to work with what you’ve got. Here are some simple swaps:

Mayonnaise: Greek yogurt or sour cream.
Cheddar Cheese: Colby, Gouda, or a mild white cheddar.
Mozzarella: Fontina or Monterey Jack.
Fresh Basil: Fresh parsley or oregano.
Green Onions: Chives or shallots.

Ingredient Spotlight

Tomatoes: Use the ripest, juiciest tomatoes you can find. Heirlooms are especially flavorful and gorgeous in this pie.
Mayonnaise: Don’t knock it. It’s the secret to that creamy, tangy layer that pulls everything together.

Instructions for Making Tomato Pie

Making tomato pie is like crafting a delicious, savory puzzle. Each layer adds flavor, and the oven brings it all together.

1. Preheat Your Equipment:
Set your oven to 375°F and allow it to preheat fully. Place a baking sheet on the middle rack to catch any drips.

2. Combine Ingredients:
In a bowl, mix the mayo, cheddar, mozzarella, basil, green onions, and black pepper until creamy and well blended.

3. Prepare Your Cooking Vessel:
If using a pre-made crust, press it into a 9-inch pie dish. Prick the bottom with a fork and par-bake for 10 minutes.

4. Assemble the Dish:
Layer sliced tomatoes in the crust. Sprinkle with salt and let them sit for 10 minutes, then pat dry. Add another layer of tomatoes, then spread the mayo-cheese mixture evenly on top.

5. Cook to Perfection:
Bake for 30 to 35 minutes or until the top is golden and bubbly.

6. Finishing Touches:
Let the pie cool for at least 10 to 15 minutes before slicing to allow the filling to set.

7. Serve and Enjoy:
Cut into wedges and serve warm or at room temperature. Enjoy the burst of garden flavor in every bite.

Texture & Flavor Secrets

This pie is all about contrasts. The crust is flaky and golden, a perfect counterpoint to the tender, juicy tomatoes. The cheese mixture melts into a creamy, tangy layer that pulls everything together. Fresh basil and green onions cut through the richness with brightness and bite.

Cooking Tips & Tricks

Here’s how to make this recipe even easier and tastier:

• Use firm tomatoes: Overripe tomatoes will make the pie watery.
• Cool before cutting: Hot pie can fall apart. Let it rest to firm up.
• Add crunch: Sprinkle breadcrumbs or crushed crackers on top for extra texture.
• Use fresh herbs: Dried just doesn’t have the same punch here.

What to Avoid

Don’t worry, mistakes happen. But here’s how to steer clear of the big ones:

• Don’t skip draining tomatoes: Soggy pie is a real letdown.
• Avoid pre-shredded cheese: They often have anti-caking agents that affect melt.
• Don’t overload filling: Too much cheese or mayo can weigh the pie down.

Nutrition Facts

Servings: 6
Calories per serving: 320

Note: These are approximate values.

Preparation Time

Prep Time: 20 minutes
Cook Time: 35 minutes
Total Time: 55 minutes

Make-Ahead and Storage Tips

Tomato pie is a wonderful make-ahead dish. You can prep it in the morning, refrigerate, and bake just before dinner. Leftovers store well in the fridge for up to 3 days. To reheat, cover loosely with foil and warm in a 300°F oven for 10 to 15 minutes.

How to Serve Tomato Pie

Tomato pie shines on its own but pairs beautifully with a light green salad, grilled chicken, or even a bowl of soup. For brunch, serve it with fruit and a mimosa. For dinner, pair with a crisp white wine and roasted vegetables.

Creative Leftover Transformations

Leftover tomato pie? Lucky you. Here’s how to reinvent it:

• Breakfast Bake: Chop and stir into scrambled eggs or a frittata.
• Tomato Grilled Cheese: Use slices as filling in a grilled sandwich.
• Pie Toast: Toast a slice and top with a fried egg for brunch vibes.

Additional Tips

• Let your pie cool uncovered: This keeps the crust crisp.
• Use heirloom tomatoes if you can: They’re juicy and add visual wow.
• A pinch of red pepper flakes: Adds subtle heat that elevates the whole dish.

Make It a Showstopper

Presentation matters. For a stunning look, use multi-colored heirloom tomatoes and arrange the slices in a spiral or shingled pattern. A few fresh basil leaves on top after baking adds vibrant color. Serve on a pretty platter and let the compliments roll in.

Variations to Try

• Southern Kick: Add diced jalapeños or hot sauce for a spicy twist.
• Caprese Style: Use fresh mozzarella and drizzle with balsamic glaze.
• Pesto Dream: Swap mayo for pesto in the cheese layer.
• Meat Lover’s: Add cooked sausage crumbles between tomato layers.
• Garden Veggie: Add thin-sliced zucchini or bell peppers for extra veg.

FAQ’s

Q1: Can I use store-bought pie crust?

Yes, it saves time and still tastes great. Just pre-bake it slightly for a crisp bottom.

Q2: What kind of tomatoes work best?

Firm, ripe tomatoes like beefsteak or heirloom are ideal.

Q3: Can I make it gluten-free?

Absolutely. Use a gluten-free pie crust and you’re good to go.

Q4: How do I prevent a watery pie?

Salt and drain your tomato slices before layering. It’s key.

Q5: Can I freeze tomato pie?

It’s not recommended. The texture gets mushy. Better to refrigerate and reheat.

Q6: Can I add bacon or ham?

Sure! Just pre-cook and drain before adding it in.

Q7: Can I use dried herbs?

Fresh is best, but if using dried, use less since the flavor is more concentrated.

Q8: Is it better served warm or cold?

Both work. Warm is cozier, cold is refreshing and perfect for summer.

Q9: Can I make this dairy-free?

Try dairy-free cheese shreds and vegan mayo as substitutes.

Q10: What side dishes go well with it?

Think green salads, grilled veggies, fruit salad, or roasted potatoes.

Conclusion

Tomato pie is the kind of recipe that feels like a warm hug from the past, but also fresh and exciting every time you make it. Whether you’re feeding a crowd or just treating yourself, this pie delivers big flavor with minimal fuss. Trust me, you’re going to love this one. Try it once, and you’ll be making it all tomato season long.

Print