Tomato Pie

If there’s one dish that sings of late summer comfort, it’s tomato pie. With every bite, you get the perfect harmony of buttery crust, roasted heirloom tomatoes, and a rich cheesy filling that makes it impossible to resist. It’s cozy, savory, and beautifully rustic. The aroma alone as it bakes is enough to draw everyone into the kitchen. Trust me, you’re going to love this one.

Behind the Recipe

Tomato pie has always had a special place in my kitchen. I remember my grandmother pulling one out of the oven, the crust golden and the scent of basil and bubbling cheese filling the air. We’d eat it warm or even chilled the next day, always savoring every bite. It’s the kind of recipe that feels like home, no matter where you are.

Recipe Origin or Trivia

This Southern staple has deep roots in American comfort food history. Originating from the southern United States, tomato pie was traditionally made to use up an abundance of garden tomatoes at the peak of summer. While it shares a name with the Italian tomato pie (which is more of a focaccia-style pizza), the Southern version is all about layering fresh tomatoes in a buttery crust with a creamy cheese topping, often with a sprinkle of fresh basil or green onions. It’s a celebration of simple, seasonal ingredients.

Why You’ll Love Tomato Pie

This dish is more than just tomatoes in a crust. Here’s why it might just become your new favorite:

Versatile: Serve it warm for dinner or chilled for lunch, as a main course or a side. It fits into any meal.

Budget-Friendly: Made with pantry basics and seasonal produce, this dish is both affordable and satisfying.

Quick and Easy: With a ready-made crust and simple prep, it’s weeknight-friendly.

Customizable: Add your own herbs, change up the cheese, or make it spicy. You do you.

Crowd-Pleasing: It’s the kind of dish that gets compliments at potlucks and family gatherings every time.

Make-Ahead Friendly: Bake it a day in advance and serve it cold or reheat it when ready.

Great for Leftovers: Tastes just as delicious the next day, maybe even better.

Chef’s Pro Tips for Perfect Results

Here’s how to make your tomato pie turn out just right every time:

• Drain Your Tomatoes: Salt and drain them to prevent a soggy crust. Juicy tomatoes are great, but not when they flood the pie.
• Prebake the Crust: Blind bake your crust until lightly golden to keep it crisp even under all that filling.
• Use Heirloom Varieties: For best flavor and color, go with a mix of red, yellow, and even purple tomatoes.
• Let It Cool Slightly: Letting it rest after baking helps the flavors set and keeps the cheese layer from sliding apart.
• Fresh Herbs Matter: Basil, chives, or green onions brighten the pie and cut through the richness.

Kitchen Tools You’ll Need

You don’t need anything fancy to pull this off, just the basics:

Pie Dish: A 9-inch dish is the perfect size for a hearty tomato pie.

Mixing Bowls: For combining the cheese and mayo mixture.

Sharp Knife: To slice the tomatoes cleanly.

Paper Towels: To pat the tomatoes dry after draining.

Baking Sheet: Placing the pie dish on a baking sheet prevents oven spills.

Ingredients in Tomato Pie

It’s the mix of juicy, cheesy, and herby that makes this pie unforgettable. Here’s what you’ll need:

1. Pie Crust: 1 9-inch pre-made or homemade crust, prebaked for structure and buttery flavor.
2. Tomatoes: 3–4 large ripe heirloom tomatoes, sliced and drained for maximum flavor with minimal sogginess.
3. Salt: 1 teaspoon, to draw moisture out of the tomatoes and season the pie.
4. Mozzarella Cheese: 1 cup shredded, for that melty cheesy base.
5. Sharp Cheddar Cheese: 1 cup shredded, adds tang and depth.
6. Mayonnaise: ½ cup, binds the cheeses into a creamy topping.
7. Fresh Basil: A handful, chopped for a fresh herbal finish.
8. Green Onions: 2, sliced thin for gentle onion flavor and extra bite.
9. Black Pepper: ½ teaspoon, just enough to balance the richness.

Ingredient Substitutions

Need to swap a few things? No problem:

Pie Crust: Puff pastry or phyllo dough can work in a pinch.

Mozzarella Cheese: Try provolone or Monterey Jack for similar meltiness.

Cheddar Cheese: Colby or gouda can stand in with a similar punch.

Mayonnaise: Greek yogurt or sour cream can be used for a lighter version.

Green Onions: Shallots or chives are great substitutes.

Ingredient Spotlight

Heirloom Tomatoes: These beauties come in vibrant colors and are naturally sweeter and less acidic than standard tomatoes. They’re key for that bold tomato flavor.

Sharp Cheddar Cheese: This cheese provides richness and a bit of sharp tang that balances the sweetness of the tomatoes.

Instructions for Making Tomato Pie

Alright, let’s get cooking. This recipe is simple and satisfying — here are the steps to make it sing.

1. Preheat Your Equipment:
Preheat your oven to 375°F (190°C). If you haven’t prebaked your crust, now’s the time.

2. Combine Ingredients:
In a bowl, mix together the shredded mozzarella, cheddar cheese, and mayonnaise. Stir until it’s creamy and evenly combined.

3. Prepare Your Cooking Vessel:
Place your prebaked pie crust on a baking sheet to catch any bubbling over.

4. Assemble the Dish:
Layer half the tomatoes over the crust. Sprinkle with salt, pepper, and some basil. Add half the cheese mixture. Repeat with the remaining tomatoes and the rest of the cheese mixture. Top with green onions and more fresh basil.

5. Cook to Perfection:
Bake for 30 to 35 minutes, or until the top is golden and bubbly.

6. Finishing Touches:
Let it rest for at least 10 to 15 minutes before slicing. This helps the filling set.

7. Serve and Enjoy:
Slice into wedges and serve warm or at room temperature. Pair it with a crisp green salad for the perfect meal.

Texture & Flavor Secrets

The true charm of tomato pie lies in contrast. The crust is flaky and buttery, the tomatoes soft and juicy, the cheese creamy and savory. That touch of fresh basil adds a pop of brightness that cuts through all the richness. Each bite is layered with comforting warmth and just the right hint of acidity.

Cooking Tips & Tricks

These little touches will make your tomato pie even better:

• Use ripe, but not overripe tomatoes for best texture.
• Don’t skip the draining step to keep the crust crisp.
• Use full-fat mayo and cheese for the creamiest results.
• Chill leftovers for a cold slice that tastes just as good.

What to Avoid

Let’s keep things smooth by dodging these pitfalls:

• Skipping tomato draining: Your pie will turn watery and mushy.
• Using too much cheese mix: It can overflow and overpower the tomatoes.
• Serving it too hot: Give it time to cool slightly or it won’t slice cleanly.

Nutrition Facts

Servings: 6
Calories per serving: 320

Note: These are approximate values.

Preparation Time

Prep Time: 20 minutes
Cook Time: 35 minutes
Total Time: 55 minutes

Make-Ahead and Storage Tips

Tomato pie is a dream when it comes to planning ahead. You can make it the day before and refrigerate it. Just reheat in the oven until warmed through or enjoy it cold. Leftovers will last up to 3 days in the fridge. Avoid freezing, as tomatoes can get watery.

How to Serve Tomato Pie

This dish is stunning on its own, but it pairs beautifully with:

• A fresh green salad with vinaigrette
• Roasted vegetables
• A glass of iced tea or lemonade

It’s just the kind of thing you want at a summer brunch or cozy dinner.

Creative Leftover Transformations

Leftovers? You’re in luck. Here’s what to do:

• Tomato Pie Toastie: Reheat a slice and sandwich it between two slices of toasted sourdough.
• Savory Breakfast Pie: Top a cold slice with a poached egg.
• Pie-Stuffed Peppers: Chop leftovers and fill into roasted bell peppers.

Additional Tips

• Let it rest before slicing so it holds together better.
• Use a serrated knife to slice cleanly through the tomatoes.
• Add a dash of hot sauce if you like a little heat.

Make It a Showstopper

Serve your tomato pie on a wooden board with a sprinkle of basil and a drizzle of olive oil. Garnish with fresh tomato slices and place it next to a small bouquet of herbs. It’ll be the centerpiece of the table in no time.

Variations to Try

• Spicy Tomato Pie: Add chopped jalapeños or red pepper flakes.
• Caprese Style: Layer in fresh mozzarella and sliced basil leaves.
• Roasted Veggie Pie: Add layers of zucchini or eggplant.
• Southern Style: Include a bit of pimento cheese in the mix.
• Mini Pies: Make in muffin tins for bite-sized versions.

FAQ’s

Q1: Can I use store-bought pie crust?

Yes, it works perfectly and saves time. Just make sure to prebake it.

Q2: Can I freeze tomato pie?

Freezing isn’t recommended due to the high moisture content of tomatoes.

Q3: What kind of tomatoes work best?

Heirloom or vine-ripened tomatoes are ideal for flavor and color.

Q4: Can I use different cheeses?

Absolutely. Just choose ones that melt well.

Q5: Is there a low-fat version?

You can try light mayo and part-skim cheese, though it may affect creaminess.

Q6: Should I peel the tomatoes?

Not necessary, but you can if you prefer a smoother texture.

Q7: How do I prevent a soggy bottom?

Salt and drain the tomatoes, and prebake the crust.

Q8: Can I make it gluten-free?

Yes, just use a gluten-free crust.

Q9: How long will it last in the fridge?

About 3 days, well covered.

Q10: Can I add meat?

Yes, cooked crumbled sausage or turkey can be added, though it’s traditionally vegetarian.

Conclusion

Tomato pie is everything you want in a comforting meal. It’s rich, fresh, cheesy, and satisfying with every bite. Whether you’re hosting a summer gathering or just want something special for dinner, this pie hits all the right notes. Give it a try, and let me tell you, it’s worth every bite.

Print